Thursday, January 22, 2015

SOCRATES (469-399 BCE)
  

“To wisely endure is courageous,
To do something else is outrageous!”
But then Socrates said
“Lake, you’re touched in the head!
The best thing is disadvantageous!”



Note: Socrates was an ugly-looking, snub-nosed, shoeless gadfly who walked around 5th century Athens asking prominent people bothersome questions, many of them of the form “What is X?”.  Young men flocked to him, no doubt entertained by his skewering of public figures whom he showed to be ignorant of the things they claimed to know.  One of these young men was Plato, who later wrote dialogues, many of them with a character called “Socrates”.  In some of these dialogues, “Socrates” stands in for the real Socrates, saying the sorts of things, and advancing the sorts of arguments, that Socrates himself likely used in his conversations, none of which he actually wrote down.  In Plato’s Laches, Socrates asks two generals, first Laches (here, “Lake”) and then Nicias, what courage is.  Laches’ main answer is that courage is wise endurance, i.e., endurance accompanied by knowledge.  Socrates then gets Laches to agree that courage is an admirable thing, but then notes that, in many cases, the admirable thing is to endure foolishly, rather than wisely.  For example, rescuers who dive into wells without knowing what they are doing are widely admired, even though they are risking their lives in the absence of relevant knowledge.    

Further note: I confess that this poem focuses on the recondite.  So I'll post a bonus limerick about Socrates later today....

Here goes:

Of smart know-it-alls there's a huge glut,
But they're dolts when you're down in a rut.
The one person to see
If your life's up a tree,
Is an ignorant pain in the ----.

Note: I hate to break it to you, but Socrates actually died of natural causes.  (Hemlock is natural.)  Story goes, he went to see the Delphic oracle, who told him that he was the wisest in all of Greece.  This brought Socrates up short, because if there was one thing he knew, it was that he was ignorant.  (Interpreters disagree about what this means.  Obviously, if Socrates knows that he doesn't know, then he knows something.  But everything one knows is true, so if Socrates knows that he doesn't know, then he doesn't know, because it's true that he doesn't know.  Ergo, so it seems, he doesn't know anything.  Contradiction.  The puzzle is solved when one realizes that Socrates doesn't mean to be telling us that he knows ab-so-lu-te-ly nothing.  He means to be telling us that he knows nothing that really matters. Sure, he knows how to tie his shoes (or maybe not, see previous note), he knows the way to Larissa, but those things don't matter.  What matters is virtue, excellence of the soul: justice, piety, courage and temperance.  And virtue is something the nature of which Socrates knows that he doesn't know.)  "If I am so ignorant," thought Socrates (though not in those words), "why does the Oracle say that I'm the wisest?"  Puzzled, Socrates walked around and found all the people who took themselves to be knowledgeable: politicians (who take themselves to know how to run the state -- they must know what justice is), generals (who take themselves to know how to fight wars -- they must know what courage is), religious prosecutors (who take themselves to distinguish between the pious and the impious -- they must know what piety is), and so on.  He asked them questions, and, soon enough, discovered that these know-it-alls didn't really know what they thought they knew.  And then the solution to the Delphic riddle hit him like a brick: "I am the wisest", he realized, "because I know that I do not know, whereas others who think they know are really ignorant."  But the politicians and generals and religious prosecutors eventually got fed up with Socrates.  He was accused of atheism and of corrupting the youth of Athens.  After he was found guilty, he snubbed his nose at the jury, arguing that his sentence should be free meals at the Prytaneum (the central Athenian cafeteria).  What a comedian!  The jurors laughed, and then prescribed hemlock instead.

Wednesday, January 21, 2015

PARMENIDES AND ZENO OF ELEA (5TH CENTURY BCE)




There were two Eleatic companions
Whose view led to two contradictions.
But with all said and done,
And things proved to be one,
They saved face with two timely corrections.



Note: Parmenides famously claimed that the all is one, round like a ball, and perfect.  Zeno came up with a number of arguments that purported to show that there couldn’t be many things, and thus that there had to be only one thing.  In the Sophist, Plato criticizes this Eleatic Monism, and it is clear that he is having fun at the Eleatics’ expense.  He points out, among other things, that in saying that what is is one, the Eleatics are committed to saying that there are two names, “being” and “one”, and that these names must name the same thing.  Unfortunately, it’s absurd to suppose that there are two names (and so two things) when there is only one thing.  He also points out that the Eleatics are committed to the view that the name “being” and the thing it names are the same thing (otherwise, they would be two things), and hence either to the absurd claim that “being” names nothing (because “being” is the same as Being, which doesn’t name anything) or to the equally absurd claim that “being” names a name (because it names itself).  All that I am doing in the poem is channeling Plato.   

Tuesday, January 20, 2015

THALES  OF MILETUS (c. 624 – c. 546 BCE)


Famed Thales loved all things aquatic,
Some ice would have made him ecstatic.
“All is water,” he said,
“That’s the world’s magic thread!”
Let's call him the first true fanatic.

Note: There is a mistake in this poem, and it’s a howler.  My daughter, Sophie, thinks that I should be fired from the position of Household Poet Laureate for it, and I agree with her.  “Aquatic”, as anyone with an ounce of familiarity with the English language will tell you, does not rhyme with “ecstatic” or “fanatic”.  But I am going to buck poetic conventions just this once, and go with what we might call “inscriptional rhyming”: if two words end with the same group of letters in the same order, then they are inscriptional rhyming pairs, just like “break” and “bleak”.  

[Update: One of our UCSD graduate students, Ryan Stringer, rightly points out that what I am calling "inscriptional rhyming" is really just what is sometimes called in the poetry biz, "off rhyming".  So what I am thinking of as a howler is really just a stroke of genius!  I knew it!  Just wait till I tell Sophie....]

[Further update: A philosopher friend from the UK, Tom Stoneham, tells me, quite rightly, that "aquatic" actually does rhyme with "fanatic" in his (wonderful) dialect.  This is confirmed by the Oxford English Dictionary.  My apologies to those of you living on the other side of the pond.  I did check with Merriam-Webster, and in the United States the two words don't form a perfect rhyme.]

Further Note: Thales really did think that all was (made out of) water.  A reasonable hypothesis, if you think about it.  First, if you’re living on the western coast of Anatolia (now Turkey), what are you looking at all day?  The Mediterranean Sea, of course.  And what is that sea made of?  Water!  And salt, of course, but that is soluble in water, which means that it must be something that can mix with water without being visibly different from water, and the only kind of thing that can do that is, well, water.  (Not well-water, that’s different.)  Second, what is Thales eating in western Turkey?  Obviously, olives.  And what happens when you squeeze an olive?  You get olive oil water.  I know it’s green and it doesn’t mix with water, but it’s liquid, isn’t it?  Third, we humans drink water, by the gallons, especially in the Turkish summer heat.  And we don’t eliminate it.  (Well, we eliminate something, but it’s not potable, so it can’t be water.)  And that means that our bodies must be made out of water.  QED. 
Today is the first of 101 days of philosophical limericks.  I would love to publish them (or more of them) as a book, but my agent thinks that the chance of this is less than the chance of my becoming the next US President.  (Word to the wise: I was born in France.)

First, a short introduction.

There are (at least) three things that I like in this world: philosophy, humor, and the possibility of immortality (though not in that order).  This led to a natural choice of career: professor of philosophy.  I thought that I would (eventually) take my rightful place in the philosophical pantheon, following immortals such as Plato, Aristotle, and Kant, by producing original and rigorous arguments that lead to surprising conclusions important to human life, such as that the propositional content of an utterance of a name is identical to the name itself.  (This was part of the point of my Ph.D. dissertation, which, to my astonishment, fell on deaf ears.)  But I soon realized that I would not be able to achieve immortality through philosophy.  Then I thought I might try stand-up comedy.  But I got up the next morning, looked in the mirror, and that was that.  So then I had a brilliant idea, even better than my dissertation topic!  Like Plato, who argues (in the Philebus) that the best kind of life is not the life of pleasure or the life of knowledge but rather a life resulting from a combination of the two, I thought that I might just become immortal if I combined humor with philosophy.  But I knew that I couldn’t do it in the manner of the true masters (such as Rogers Albritton and Jerry Cohen).  So it would have to be through something I knew absolutely nothing about: poetry.  (For those of you who care about these things, that was a non sequitur.) 

Actually, I’m pulling your leg.  The true story is this.  In the spring of 2014, I received an email message asking me whether I would be willing to contribute something to an event that was being held at UCLA to honor my dissertation advisor and mentor, David Kaplan, on the occasion of his 80th birthday.  I couldn’t make it to the Kaplan-fest, so I decided that I would try my hand at writing something that would express my admiration for him, with a little humor mixed in.  I didn’t have much time, so I tried thinking of a limerick with a first line ending in “Kaplan”.  Good luck to me!  It turns out that there are five words (including “plan”) ending in “plan”, but no words ending in “aplan”.  So I took it as a challenge to find a limerick that would work.  In the end, I came up with two, which I will share with you in due time.  And then I found that I couldn’t stop thinking of limericks.  Limericking became something of an obsession, crowding out other forms of useful activity (such as shopping for food, making dinner, and so on).  So, to my wife, Dana, and to our daughters, Sophie and Alice, I offer this apology:  Yes, it really is all my fault that you didn’t eat or drink for several weeks, and for that I am truly sorry.

As you read through the poems I post, please keep the following things in mind.  There is no rhyme or reason (well, there is rhyme, actually, and quite a bit of reason, frankly) to them, except that I have tried to follow a few rules of thumb. 

The first is that the reader should be entertained.  Some poems are accurate (or very close to accurate).  Whatever entertainment the reader derives from them is designed to be, at least in part, a function of their accuracy.  Other poems are not designed to be all that accurate: they simply represent my own very biased judgment.  Whatever entertainment the reader derives from them is designed to be, at least in part, a function of their inaccuracy.  In some cases, I try to distill the essence of some philosophical position into five lines.  In other cases, I don’t even pretend to do this.  Please do not infer, then, that my view is that all of Plato (or Augustine, or Cavendish, or Kamm) can be reduced to a limerick.  That would be unfair to these great philosophers, whose work speaks, and should be read, for itself.

The second is that much (though not all) of what I say that is or appears critical of famous philosophers is tongue-in-cheek, and should be taken with the good humor in which it was composed.  I can think of only two exceptions: you will know them when you read them.  Those are protest poems, if you will. 

The third is that I have chosen to highlight many who have been my mentors, or whose work had a profound personal influence on me or on my own work.  Looking back, I see how important these people were to my own life.  (I am thinking, in particular, of John Rawls, David Kaplan, Keith Donnellan, Philippa Foot, Tyler Burge, Warren Quinn, Robert M. Adams, and Barbara Herman.)  I thank them all, from the bottom of my heart.  Had it not been for them, I would not have written the drivel work that helps keep food on my family’s kitchen table (when there is any—see above).

The fourth, which is something of a corollary to the third, is that if I have not yet written a poem about X, please do not infer that I do not think much of X’s work.  Chances are that I really, really do.  But I gave myself an artificial limit of 101 limericks (at least, to start with), and this meant that I had to make arbitrary decisions about whom to target and whom to pass over.  If you would like me to compose a limerick about a favorite philosopher of yours, let me know.  That philosopher might just be included in the next blog sequence, which will become a blockbuster, as soon as I get my act together and get an agent.

The fifth is that, although I have focused on philosophers whose work I know well (e.g., Plato, Locke, Berkeley), I have also included poems about philosophers whose work is not (yet) part of the philosophical canon.  This is because I think that their work should be read and appreciated, sometimes for its influence, but mostly for its stimulating content.  

The sixth is that one poem (about Anselm) was actually produced by my illustrious wife and colleague, Dana Kay Nelkin.  She had the brilliant idea of imagining a reversal of the conversation between Anselm and Gaunilo.  If you like the limerick she wrote, you should thank her.  But I’m keeping the royalties (as soon as this blog goes viral).

With all these caveats and qualifications in mind, I hope you enjoy these limericks at least half as much as I enjoyed writing them.  It was a labor of love, and I am very happy to be able to share it with you.